Posts
If Part One named what collapsed, and Part Two named who was protected, Part Three names what can no longer be asked.
Because thinning is not only about attendance.
It is about authority.
Loyalty is no longer the highest virtue
For a long time, church culture treated loyalty as unquestioned good.
Staying was praised.
Enduring was sanctified.
Leaving was suspect.
But trauma changes the moral calculus.
After collective suffering, loyalty that ignores harm is no longer faithfulness.
It is avoidance.
And many people sensed this without needing language for it.
They did not leave because they became disloyal.
They left because loyalty stopped feeling morally neutral.
When loyalty conflicts with truth, something has to give
COVID forced a reckoning few institutions were prepared for.
People watched leaders prioritize stability over care.
Narrative over naming.
Momentum over mourning.
For those already carrying grief, this created an internal fracture.
They were being asked to remain loyal to systems that could not tell the truth about pain.
That is not a small ask.
Eventually, something broke.
Not belief.
Consent.
Authority is changing shape
Before the thinning, authority often rested on position.
Title.
Tenure.
Visibility.
Confidence.
After trauma, authority rests elsewhere.
It now flows toward those who can do three things:
tell the truth without defensiveness
remain present without fixing
acknowledge harm without rushing to absolution
This kind of authority cannot be asserted.
It is recognized.
And it cannot be rushed.
Why some leaders feel abandoned
From the inside, thinning can feel personal.
Leaders may experience it as betrayal, ingratitude, or loss of trust.
But what is often happening is something quieter and harder.
People are no longer willing to carry unresolved dissonance on behalf of leadership.
They are not withdrawing love.
They are withdrawing false agreement.
That distinction matters.
The church is losing its ability to demand coherence it has not earned
For years, many people performed coherence for the sake of belonging.
They smoothed over contradictions.
They spiritualized disappointment.
They made peace with what did not sit right.
Trauma removed the energy required for that performance.
Now, when words and actions do not align, people notice.
And they no longer translate that misalignment into patience.
They translate it into distance.
What leadership looks like after thinning
Leadership in the post COVID church will feel slower and less impressive.
It will include:
long pauses that are not filled
questions that remain open
confession without immediate repair
willingness to lose people rather than distort reality
This kind of leadership cannot scale quickly.
But it can be trusted.
The cost of refusing this shift
Churches that attempt to restore pre COVID expectations will continue to thin.
Not because people are lazy.
Not because faith has weakened.
But because moral awareness has sharpened.
You cannot ask traumatized people to perform belonging.
You cannot frame endurance as discipleship when it erodes personhood.
And you cannot reclaim authority by insisting on loyalty alone.
What is being born is quieter and more costly
The future church will not be held together by obligation.
It will be held together by consent.
By people who choose presence knowing the cost.
By leaders who tell the truth even when it reduces numbers.
By communities willing to move at the speed of trust.
This church will look fragile.
But it will be real.
After loyalty loses its moral weight
Thinning is forcing the church to answer a question it avoided for generations:
What do we do when staying is no longer the most faithful option?
The answer unfolding now is uncomfortable.
Sometimes, obedience looks like departure.
Sometimes, faithfulness looks like refusal.
Sometimes, love requires leaving what cannot love you back.
This does not mean the church has failed.
It means it is being stripped down to what can no longer hide.
And what survives that stripping will not be large.
But it may finally be honest.
And honesty is the ground on which anything worth building must stand.
No comments:
Post a Comment