Posts
Most churches do not intend to harm people.
They intend to form faith.
And yet formation always happens somewhere.
Often it happens not only in beliefs, but in what the body learns to tolerate.
The book of Jonah offers a quiet way to see this.
Jonah does not struggle because he misunderstands God.
His theology is accurate.
He knows God is gracious, merciful, slow to anger, abounding in steadfast love.
What Jonah cannot tolerate is what that mercy asks of him.
His body tells the story his words cannot.
Jonah obeys but his body shuts down
Jonah sleeps through the storm.
Not because he trusts God, but because his system is overwhelmed.
He would rather be thrown into the sea than remain emotionally present.
He would rather die than be changed by mercy.
This is not rebellion.
It is survival.
And that is where Jonah begins to feel uncomfortably familiar.
How churches unintentionally form “Jonah bodies”
Churches rarely do this on purpose.
But certain well-intended patterns can quietly train people to survive rather than heal.
When endurance is praised more than honesty
Many churches celebrate those who stay.
Who keep serving.
Who keep showing up.
Who endure quietly.
What is less often named with the same reverence:
-
naming limits
-
telling the truth when it is inconvenient
-
leaving when something no longer holds life
Over time, the body learns:
Pain is safest when it is contained, not expressed.
Faithfulness becomes synonymous with override.
Jonah can obey.
Jonah can preach.
Jonah can endure.
But his body has never learned that honest pain will be held.
When theology substitutes for safety
Churches are often skilled at teaching truth.
They are less practiced at helping people feel safe enough to feel.
So theology quietly becomes:
-
a regulator for anxiety
-
a bypass for grief
-
a way to remain upright without remaining present
People learn to quote what is true instead of staying with what hurts.
Jonah knows who God is.
But his body cannot tolerate what God does.
That gap is not sin.
It is formation without integration.
When leaders model certainty instead of presence
Many leaders are rewarded for clarity, decisiveness, and answers.
They are rarely rewarded for:
-
staying with pain
-
not fixing
-
admitting uncertainty
-
saying “I don’t know, but I’m here”
Over time, people learn often unconsciously:
If I am undone, I am behind.
Grief becomes something to manage quickly rather than metabolize slowly.
Jonah lives under this pressure.
So do many faithful people.
When grief is rushed toward meaning
Churches love resurrection language and rightly so.
But sometimes resurrection is offered before burial is honored.
People are encouraged to:
-
forgive before they have grieved
-
praise before they have protested
-
move on before they have integrated
The result is not healing, but tightening.
Pain survives by becoming rigid.
Resentment forms quietly.
Mercy begins to feel destabilizing.
Jonah is not angry because God is cruel.
He is angry because mercy threatens the fragile structure holding him together.
When leaving is framed as failure
Perhaps the most formative message of all.
If leaving a church is framed—explicitly or implicitly—as:
-
rebellion
-
lack of submission
-
spiritual drift
then people learn to override their own signals in order to remain “faithful.”
They stay long after their bodies know something is wrong.
Jonah obeys while dissociating.
Many church members do the same.
God stays with Jonah but Jonah is not the destination
One of the most tender truths in Jonah is that God does not abandon him.
God asks questions.
God provides shade.
God stays present even with Jonah’s resentment.
But the story also shows the limits of survival-based faith.
Jonah ends still standing outside the city.
Still resistant.
Still unintegrated.
That matters.
Jonah is not a model to imitate.
He is a mirror to recognize.
What comes after Jonah
There is another way faith can live in the body.
A faith that:
-
does not require self-erasure
-
does not confuse endurance with holiness
-
does not rush pain toward meaning
-
does not demand certainty as proof of trust
A faith where mercy does not erase pain but holds it.
Some people discover this slowly, often through grief.
Through leaving places they once loved.
Through realizing that staying is no longer faithfulness but self-abandonment.
When that realization comes, leaving often does not look angry or dramatic.
It looks quiet.
Clear.
Complete.
Presence is no longer something to negotiate.
And that is not rejection.
It is completion.
A final word for anyone still inside Jonah
For anyone who recognizes themselves here:
You are not weak.
You are not faithless.
You are not failing.
You may simply be surviving in a system that taught endurance more thoroughly than healing.
God is patient with Jonah bodies.
God stays.
But God also leads some people quietly, gently beyond Jonah.
Not away from faith.
Into embodiment.
And when that happens, leaving does not look like rebellion.
It looks like truth finally allowed to live in the body.
